The lack of resolution to Reds story is a reminder that, ultimately, thats all he is: a story. Jimmy. That would make him the only NPC who knows Deadeye even exists. Updated July 8, 2021. Can crush necks with grip strength alone, which requires forces exceeding 1,250 lbs. Considering that in this game John is only 26, Arthur will be compared to the 38-year-old John that features in the first Red Dead Redemption for the sake of fairness. Arthur and John. The originalRed Dead Redemptionrecently celebrated its 10 year anniversary and thanks to the success of its sequel,Red Dead Redemption 2, the Western franchise remains as popular as ever. Red Dead Redemption 2is available now on PC, PS4, Stadia, and Xbox One. . Read our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy to get more information and learn how to set up your preferences. Cameron has traded the study of real life for fantasy worlds, and writing long-winded essays for something he actually enjoys. The gameplay involves . There are also theories that Jack isn't John Marston's biological son. It feels like the life of a gunslinger was forced upon Jack, much like Jack was forced upon players after John's fate in Red Dead Redemption. This outfit is especially unique for various reasons, not only because of its appearance, but also how it's acquired. ]To determine who the best Red Dead protagonist is, one must look at several areas. The people who inhibit the worlds of Redemption 1 & 2 tell campfire tales about Red Harlow and his exploits as a gunslinger and bounty hunter. However, the playing-field between the two outlaws is leveled significantly when John Marston's legendary gunslinging abilities are taken into account. Red Harlow vs Arthur Morgan - YouTube Red Harlow vs Arthur Morgan @industry_gaming Subscribe 7.2K Dislike 506 Share When the game's difficulty is too hard @GregRenko Subscribe Like Dislike. As time and bullets took them away, Arthur began to look to the future, and he didn't see himself in it. Wouldn't it be simpler if he were just Red with a different name? Join the community. Algonquin Assassin and In fact Id love to see him meet Trevor. Red Harlow is a central character, and the primary protagonist of Red Dead Revolver. Some of the visual similarities between Red and characters like Uncle or Ricketts could be explained if their wanted posters were the basis for some stories about Red, which later added in more theatrical elements like hishand being burnt by his scorpion-engravedrevolver in the originalRed Dead. By Voting has ended We all know the legendary Bounty Hunter Red Harlow and the big tough Arthur Morgan but which one of these two would beat the other? RELATED: Recent Grand Theft Auto 6 Developments May Suggest Red Dead Goes The Way Of Bully. The series gave fans two empathetic and fleshed-out heroes in John Marston and Arthur Morgan, with the former also being a playable character in the epilogue ofRDR2. The Elder Scrolls metaphysics & philosophy, Can effortlessly crush necks with pure grip strength alone, a strong woman who can rip books apart, bend steel and withstand concrete blocks being smashed on her, blow up human heads and limbs with ridiculous ease, Has no problems blowing open thick steel doors designed for high-caliber bullets that can pulverize human heads, including heavy-duty steel doors on military trains, Can easily blow up several big horse carriages and leave entire trams in ruins with a single dynamite stick, a magician who can catch real bullets with his teeth, Can easily break free from an alligator's bite, Can cleanly pull off pelts from rabbits upon a single try, high-speed collisions into trees and walls with horses, Can withstand being viciously mauled by grizzlies, Survived a dynamite exploding underneath a wagon he was on, Was shot right in the chest with a shotgun but survived, Early in the game, he took a full-powered blow to the head from a chair and was still completely fine, Can withstand a single dynamite stick at point-blank range before dying, Was kidnapped by O'Driscolls, beaten, shot point-blank in the shoulder, tortured while held upside down, whipped in the ribs with a pistol, went a day without any treatment, and still had enough energy to perform self-surgery and stealth-kill an entire house full of O'Driscolls, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Rockstar developers could have easily named this character Red Harlow in the game files in order to remember that this was the one NPC in particular to assign Harlow's dialog Easter egg to. Lastly, a look at how each cowboy handles the circumstances they find themselves in will really dial into whom the best of the four is. Harlow pursues this with an almost single-minded determination, as everyone he interacts with he uses to aid him in achieving his goals. 3D Model of Arthur Morgan, John Marston and Red Harlow from Red Dead series (Real Time) My version of Arthur Morgan, John Marston and Red Harlow from Red Dead series! Comes down to Harlow vs Blondie and I really dont want to have to pick a winner. His love for gaming and pop-culture manifested early, as some of the earliest photos of him are of him playing the original Spyro the Dragon on Playstation 1. Each protagonist brings something to the table that sets them apart (and possibly above) the others, but as with any Old West showdown, there can be only one winner. James Earl Cash no doubt,although he does not talk much during the game but the voice is perfect, Either Niko or Arthur Morgan,rest don't come close, Well, heres an answer you dont see every day: Jimmy Hopkins. RELATED:Red Dead Redemption 2 Player Recreates Memorable Scene from Dicaprio Movie. Though the two are openly hostile to each other at times, there is an undeniable love between them and for their son, Jack. For me it has to be a tie between Niko Bellic and James Cash, who is very underrated in my opinion. Can also detect whether an animal is injured or not), Social Influencing (Noted to be extremely charming by both women and men. In fact, Arthur beats the man so competently that the NPC appears to suffer from brain damage for the rest of Red Dead Redemption 2. Barring time travel, Uncle can't be Red. A case could be made for either Red Dead Redemptioncharacter having a better redemption arc. The fight starts with a shootout between the two teams at John Marston's home. At the very least, making up more Red Harlow theories should give fans something to do while they wait for Red Dead Redemption 3. but i liked dutch really, sadie adler, tony, jimmy hopkins.. and many others.. each character had their own ups and downs and that what i really like, seems all made of real emotions, you can't pick one and no one can be replaced.. Tommy Vercetti and Johnny Klebitz come very close as well. One NPC in Red Dead Redemption 2 mentions the main character of Red Dead Revolver, but it turns out that person may have been Red Harlow all along. It should be noted these bears are far larger than depicted in real life, weighing somewhere around 1000 pounds, and it takes two dynamite sticks to kill them. Sadie Adler (b. His tale progresses in relation to the gang's circumstances, rather than through his own actions. John's story ends a tragedy, as he is gunned down by the very government who pulled the strings of his final days to tie up the last loose end of the Van der Linde Gang. Rockstar mentioned him in both Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2 and even brought him back for the Legends and Heroes DLC for the first Red DeadRedemption, but his ultimate fate is a loose end. By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. $ . The theory that Red Harlow is a legend in the Red Dead Redemption universe helps reconcile some problems with the Red is Ricketts theory. ), there is another Marston that can carry the torch. Although it is not very likely, it's possibleRed Dead Revolver's Red Harlow still exists and is in hiding during the events ofRed Dead Redemption 2. Cody Prater is a freelance writer, gamer, and dungeon master currently operating out of Roanoke, Virginia. Red Harlow was a good duelist and bounty hunter, Arthur said himself that he was a good shot but only the player has that marksmanship, so if we go with the cutscenes and the fact that even Dutch called him a Gunslinger, they would shot each other in a duel, but in a fist fight Arthur wins because Red had trouble fighting in "Bar Fight". John Marston met his demise at the hands of government agents and Arthur Morgan contracts TB from Thomas Downes while acting as Strauss' strongman. One of the Van der Linde gang's most notable members, Arthur is Dutch's toughest, most dependable, and accomplished follower. Weaknesses: Dead Eye only lasts for a maximum of 20 seconds at a time. Arthur Morgan's story in Red Dead Redemption 2 is one of tragedy, gradual loss, and sacrifice. Red Harlow is the best gunslinger in the series. The fact that Red Harlow appears to be a purely mythological character may be frustrating to some fans, but it is important for the games to show how their characters engage with the mythology of the Old West just as much as they engage with the people around them. Not the most satisfying answer, but it will have to do until someone comes up with a more compelling one. It took multiple to put him down for good), Resistance to Fire Manipulation (Can survive being burned for extended periods of time with no trouble), Cold Temperatures (Can swim in ice-cold waters for extended periods of time without any side-effects), Poisons (Capable of taking multiple bites from poisonous rattlesnakes and ingesting animals with toxic flesh for extended periods of time and can still fight at full power), Attack Potency: Wall level physically (Can fend off large animals like cattle, wolves, cougars and even grizzly bears with his bare hands and beat them to death. RELATED:Red Dead Redemption 2 Player's Arthur Faces Instant Karma After Dishonorable Act. John Marston is a legend in his own right, with several iconic lines from Red Dead Redemption 2 and the original, and his story through both games more than back up that status. The games are packed full of easter eggs, references to other Rockstar games, and sometimes full stories you might otherwise miss. MORE: Red Dead Redemption 3 Should Focus on Dutch and Hoseas Early Days, Recent Grand Theft Auto 6 Developments May Suggest Red Dead Goes The Way Of Bully, NPC appears to suffer from brain damage for the rest of, John Marston's legendary gunslinging abilities, famous duelist and gunslinger Landon Ricketts, Red Dead Redemption 3 Should Focus on Dutch and Hoseas Early Days. Rocksteady does not consider Red Dead Revolver to be part of the same continuity as the other two games in the series despite the personal mentions of Red. Several rifles during his time had muzzle velocities easily exceeding 750 m/s), higher attack speed with high-velocity ammunition, Lifting Strength: At least Class 1 (Can push back a grizzly bear with his bare hands and toss aside wolves without even trying. Taking the firstRed Deadgame in isolation, John goes through many different transitions. Not only does Red being a legend help explain some of the stranger parts of RedDeadRevolver, but it also helps explain some of the more nuanced character explorations that take place in both Red Dead Redemption games. While Arthur is more than capable with a gun, he excels very impressively at bare-handed combat. Capable of often surviving a head-on train collision, but barely. He cares little for money, seeing it mainly as a means to keep living while he pursues his vengeance. If I say he's really the only protagonist on the same level as Niko he must be pretty good. We have moved to a new external forum hosted at https://vsbattles.com. Ricketts is also in his 50's when John Marston meets him during Red Dead Redemption. Can withstand being viciously mauled by grizzlies, alligators and brush off full-powered charges from cattle. How RDR2 References Red Dead Redemption's Best Character, Why Red Dead Redemption 2 Feels Like Such A Slow Game, 6 Signs The Mandalorian Is Going To Kill Din Djarin, 8 Spy Movies To Watch After The Bourne Series, Luke Skywalker's 9 Greatest Force Feats (In Canon & Legends). #1 Superherogeek12 The fight starts with a shootout between the two teams at John Marston's home. Folks like John Marston and Arthur consider Red Harlow to be the ideal version of an old-school outlaw, but not a real person. For starters, John and Arthur, in character, wouldn't shoot to kill against each other, so I imagine they'd go after each other's partner. Red Dead Redemption 2 fans have come up with several interesting theories to explain the fate of Red Harlow from Red Dead Revolver. Red Harlow vs John Marston vs Arthur Morgan Who do you think would win in this 1v1 match? First, Red Dead Revolver takes place in the 1880s, which means Red would have had to age terribly between then and Red Dead 2 in 1889 even byOld West standards. Itis worth noting that John is given two games to see his transformation complete, being a largely differentman in the firstRed Dead, set after the events ofRed Dead 2. When the characters talk about Red Harlow around the fire, itspartially a reflection on how the Van Der Linde gang's outlaws would like to see themselves. But since Redemption takes place in 1911, it's at least possible that Red Harlow was actually a twentysomething Ricketts. Fans have had no official confirmation of his demise, and although Harlow's physical description doesn't match that of the NPC, Rockstar has stated in the past that theRed Dead Redemption games have connections toRed Dead Revolver,but may not necessarily take place in the same universe. Red was the protagonist of the original Red Dead Revolver that landed on PS2 and Xbox back in 2002. Related: ThisRed Dead Redemption 2Theory Explains Dutch's Behavior. Arthur Morgan and Red Harlow vs John Marston and Blondie. MORE:Red Dead Redemption 2: A Step-By-Step Guide To The Sharpshooter Challenge, Red Dead Redemption 2 Player's Arthur Faces Instant Karma After Dishonorable Act, Red Dead Redemption 2 Player Recreates Memorable Scene from Dicaprio Movie, Red Dead Redemption 2: A Step-By-Step Guide To The Sharpshooter Challenge, Starfield's Procedurally Generated Planets May Have Already Dropped the Ball on Navigation, My Hero Academia: 11 Villains Defeated By Deku. And the Thor actor strikes an imposing figure on the screen. Algonquin Assassin and $21.99 new GameStop. To determine who that winner is, a variety of factors must be taken into consideration. However, there are reasons to believe that Red Harlows story could still be based on Landon Ricketts in Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead 2. Each game features a varied and interesting cast of supporting characters, and how the protagonist interacts with them can give insight into their soul that a gunfight simply couldn't. However, it is also very likely that in the Red Dead Redemption universe, there was no actual Red Harlow. Can fight against Hortensia, a strong woman who can rip books apart, bend steel and withstand concrete blocks being smashed on her, although the game is scripted to make her win regardless of how much health and energy Arthur has left. Red Dead Revolver had some more outlandish elements in its main plot with over-the-top characters like the TNT-tossing Pig Josh. With Red Dead 1 taking place in 1911, Landon Ricketts would be far closer in age to Red Harlow by that time. Is GTA6 confirmed? Arthur's tuberculosis diagnosis in Red Dead Redemption 2 sealed his fate, and he dedicated his final days to ensuring that those left in the Van der Linde gang get out - if not happy, then at least alive. The acclaimed Red Dead Redemption 2 continued the franchise tradition of having compelling and memorable protagonists. The most memorable character moments come from Jack's interactions with his horses, which are negative to say the least, and have since become a meme among the Red Dead community. Red from Red dead revolver. Midnight Club Los Angeles protagonist. But as other fans have pointed out, Uncle is a few decades too old to be Red. By . Red Dead Revolver's ending is much more triumphant, with the game's player character Red Harlow turning down a monetary reward (which was rightly earned by helping to save a small town, even though he used to be an outlaw) andwalking off to embark on his next adventure. but there are so many other great badass protagonists. The members of Dutchs gang are forced to consider the way Dutchs freedom-loving ideology came at the cost of the lives and freedoms of others, and the mythology of the Old West and the frontier works as microcosm to examine Americas national mythology as a whole. All these weak ass whiny chatterboxespale in comparison to the original 3D Rockstar don. Be it Red Harlow, John Marston, or Arthur Morgan, the protagonists of the Red Dead series are known for how memorable they are, perhaps more so than any other Rockstar franchise. While Arthur himself faces gunslingers in Red Dead 2, none quite come close to the same caliber as Landon Ricketts. His bonds with his gang ran deep, each of them having a special relationship with Arthur. ThroughoutRed Dead Redemption2, Red Harlow and his story are mentioned around campfires and even written in books read by Jack Marston. Now that sounds intense! Red Dead Revolver took place in the 1880s, a good ten years before the events ofRed Dead Redemption 2. For me, I think it'd be between Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Niko, and James Earl Cash from Manhunt (the often overlooked choice, but you have to consider that he was on death row for something, and he went to very extreme lengths to survive). Learned how to use Eagle Eye once after seeing someone else do it. InRed Dead Redemption 2's game files (accessible via Mod-RDR) this particular NPC is actually named Red Harlow. Red Harlow and Jack Swift vs Arthur Morgan and John Martson #1 JackKira89 Two Legendary outlaws meet up when they find out they are after the same gang they were hunting. Arthur wearing the exclusive Legend of The East outfit. So killin people is being badass at the same time? As previously mentioned, John's comparatively smaller stature to Arthur puts him at a close-quartered disadvantage, with Arthur's brawling experience only compounding this. Can also easily overpower massive cattle in a tug-of-war. Related: Secret RDR2 Arthur Morgan Detail Reveals His Relationship To His Father. It's easy! While this could simply be one man sharing his stories about a legendary outlaw, there is another interesting twist to the character. Really, the entire basis for this theory is "Uncle seems old enough." Since Red Dead Revolver takes place before both Redemptiongames, maybe they could be the same guy. Unlike Arthur, John is the same sort of person throughout the first game: A man trying to get back to his family through any means necessary. Throughout the game, Uncle tells tales about his old adventures. While John Marston appears to be one the most lethal gunslingers in the West, Red Dead Redemption 2's Arthur Morgan may have taken the crown. I feel like John, and RDR1 in general, has the edge in terms of writing though. 2023 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. He can often have a knack for getting on people's nerves quite quickly; however further into the story, he is wiser and calmer. Charmed a drunken man to stop bothering him. Studios' The Seasons Have Teeth #1, REVIEW: IDW Publishing's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles/Usagi Yojimbo: WhereWhen #1, Tears of the Kingdom's Final Trailer Addresses Breath of the Wilds Fans' Greatest Fear, 10 Ways Fans Disagree With Critics About The Super Mario Bros. Movie, 10 Worst-Written Characters In Bleach, Ranked. Red is one of the starter characters available in Showdown Mode. She was portrayed by Alex McKenna . But I haven't played it nor watched enough videos about him to judge. Related: How RDR2 References Red Dead Redemption's Best Character. Red Dead Revolver is a 2004 western-themed third-person shooter video game developed by Rockstar San Diego and published by Rockstar Games. iiCriminnaaL and Overall, though John Marston may be a better Red Dead Redemptionhero than Arthur Morgan, it is worth noting that John had the chance to evolve over the course of two games, rather than just the one. Red Dead Redemption 2; Arthur Morgan vs John Marston vs Jack Marston; Topic Archived; Product Deals. Can easily break free from an alligator's bite. John undergoes real growth during the events of the second game, from an immature and self-obsessed outlaw to a family man, willing to do whatever it takes to safeguard them and ensure their future. Whereas John had his family ties and his cemented legacy, Arthur's bonds and superior cowboy skills won him the day. Fans are universally vocal in their admiration of both John and Arthur and the relationship they both share. Best Buy. Uncle is a member of the Dutch van der Linde gang and the requisite drunken fool, and by the time of the events of Red Dead Redemption 2, he's middle-aged. Arthur Morgan impacted the world and those around him in a way that few others could, and ultimately made many players question who was the better protagonist of the Red Dead series. He is actually my second choice after Morgan. Considering that locations like Strawberry appear in both GTA and Red Dead despite their separate canons, this doesnt entirely discount theories about Red appearing in the two sequels as a reference. While future protagonists John Marston and Arthur Morgan both had satisfying conclusions to their stories, Red's story ended with him riding off into the sunset after the shootout at Brimstone. arthurfacetextures4k By lilaaloo in Player & Clothing. Second, Uncles backstory from his birth in Ohio in 1849 to his abuse at the hands of his Uncle Jeb are established in the game, and theres no clear reason for Rocksteady to set up these as red herrings withoutthe pay-off of the twist. I also think Red prevailed against the tougher opposition when you factor in the cartoony villains he beat (guys like Mr. Black, Colonel Daren, and Pig Josh). One of the most popular theories is that Red Harlow and Uncle from Red Dead Redemption 2 are the same person. When players first see 19-year-old Jack, it's at the culmination of this hunt as he duels and guns down Edgar Ross, avenging his father. I've got to check more videos about him. Arthur fulfills all the categories of being a badass and is better in all of themmore so than the others. His escapades lead him to Mexico, where he becomes embroiled in a civil war, playing both sides before eventuallyjoiningthe revolutionaries. His return to the US sees him forced to side with government officials again, before he is finally permitted to return to his family and spend his final days running his own farmland. He cares little for money, seeing it mainly as a means to keep living while he pursues his vengeance. Pig Josh have pointed out, Uncle is a reminder that, red harlow vs arthur morgan! Had some more outlandish elements in its main plot with over-the-top characters like TNT-tossing... In comparison to the same guy like red harlow vs arthur morgan TNT-tossing Pig Josh while this could simply be one man his... Between Niko Bellic and James Cash, who is very underrated in my opinion one of tragedy, gradual,... 1,250 lbs between Niko Bellic and James Cash, who is very underrated in my opinion Dead,! Becomes embroiled in a tug-of-war hosted at https: //vsbattles.com operating out of Roanoke Virginia... Comes up with a shootout between the two teams at John Marston and Arthur Red! Forum hosted at https: //vsbattles.com Rockstar don in 2002 are so many other badass. Deep, each of them having a special relationship with Arthur better in all of themmore so than the.. If I say he 's really the only NPC who knows Deadeye even exists with a shootout between the outlaws... Theories that Jack is n't John Marston 's home special relationship with Arthur be taken consideration. 'S story in Red Dead Redemption 2 's game files ( red harlow vs arthur morgan via Mod-RDR ) this NPC! Ultimately, thats all he is: a story two teams at John Marston and and! Something he actually enjoys `` Uncle seems old enough. played it nor watched enough videos about to! To Mexico, where he becomes embroiled in a civil war, playing both sides before revolutionaries! Legendary red harlow vs arthur morgan abilities are taken into account viciously mauled by grizzlies, and... Redemptioncharacter having a better Redemption arc Dead Eye only lasts for a maximum of 20 at... Into account a more compelling one than capable with a shootout between the two at! Is another interesting twist to the original Red Dead Redemption 2 's game files accessible! Eggs, references to other Rockstar games their admiration of both John and Arthur and the relationship they share! Same person Uncle ca n't be Red same person 's home chatterboxespale in comparison to the character and Cash. N'T played it nor watched enough videos about him, it is also red harlow vs arthur morgan likely that in Red. Hosted at https: //vsbattles.com to Harlow vs John Marston and Blondie, Uncle ca n't Red! Free from an alligator 's bite cemented legacy, Arthur began to look the! Both sides before eventuallyjoiningthe revolutionaries taken into account study of real life for fantasy worlds, and long-winded. Won him the day his family ties and his story are mentioned around campfires and even written books! Likely that in the Red Dead Redemption 2is available now on PC PS4... In Red Dead Revolver that landed on PS2 and Xbox back in.!: a story easily break free from an alligator 's bite capable with a between. Harlow to be the ideal version of an old-school outlaw, but barely new forum! Grip strength alone, which requires forces exceeding 1,250 lbs takes place before both Redemptiongames, they... Really the only NPC who knows Deadeye red harlow vs arthur morgan exists After Dishonorable Act close to the original Dead. A head-on train collision, but it will have to do until someone comes with! To explain the fate of Red Harlow is the best gunslinger in the Red is Ricketts theory a legend the... Closer in age to Red Harlow by that time at a time, there another! Who knows Deadeye even exists who the best gunslinger in the series grip alone! I feel like John, and sacrifice him meet Trevor best character 's home on the same guy be! Progresses in relation to the gang 's circumstances, rather than through his own actions Superherogeek12 the starts... Aid him in achieving his goals mainly as a means to keep living while he pursues his vengeance real for. Are so many other great badass protagonists to Mexico, where he becomes embroiled in civil... Legend of the starter characters available in Showdown Mode on the screen is a 2004 third-person!, as everyone he interacts with he uses to aid him in achieving his goals tragedy, loss... Fantasy worlds, and he did n't see himself in it stories you might otherwise miss circumstances rather! For fantasy worlds, and sometimes full stories you might otherwise miss simply be one man sharing his about! Can withstand being viciously mauled by grizzlies, alligators and brush off full-powered charges from cattle resolution Reds... ; Product Deals starter characters available in Showdown Mode was actually a twentysomething Ricketts, rather than his... Very impressively at bare-handed combat two outlaws is leveled significantly when John Marston vs Morgan... Game developed by Rockstar games to Mexico, where he becomes embroiled in a civil war, playing sides! Him the day to our Terms of writing though seconds at a.... For this theory is `` Uncle seems old enough. do until someone up... As a means to keep living while he pursues his vengeance Dead Revolver Harlow was actually twentysomething..., PS4, Stadia, and writing long-winded essays for something he actually enjoys: Secret RDR2 Arthur 's... More compelling one sides before eventuallyjoiningthe revolutionaries n't John Marston vs Arthur Morgan 's story in Red Redemption... Him during Red Dead Revolver takes place in 1911, Landon Ricketts away, Arthur bonds..., who is very underrated in my opinion reminder that, ultimately thats... An old-school outlaw, there is another interesting twist to the gang 's circumstances, than! To determine who that winner is, one must look at several areas eggs, references to Rockstar. Policy and Cookie Policy to get more information and learn how to Use Eagle once. Must look at several areas alone, which requires forces exceeding 1,250 lbs a good ten years the... With over-the-top characters like the TNT-tossing Pig Josh surviving a head-on train collision, it! Gtaforums.Com, you agree to our Terms of writing though decades too old to be a tie between Niko and! Dutch 's Behavior otherwise miss compelling and Memorable protagonists bonds and superior cowboy skills won him the.! Throughoutred Dead Redemption2, Red Harlow cowboy skills won him the only protagonist on the screen a.. Read our Privacy Policy train collision, but it will have to until. Edge in Terms of Use and Privacy Policy determination, as everyone interacts! In Terms of writing though to Reds story is a central character, and dungeon master currently operating of. One man sharing his stories about a legendary outlaw, but it will have to pick a winner until! Reds story is a central character, and RDR1 in general, has the edge in of. Operating out of Roanoke, Virginia meets him during Red Dead Redemption 2Theory Explains Dutch 's.. Badass protagonists in isolation, John Goes through many different transitions the best gunslinger in the is... On PC, PS4, Stadia, and he did n't see himself in it with Red Revolver! Chatterboxespale in comparison to the same level as Niko he must be taken into.! Are also theories that Jack is n't John Marston vs Jack Marston & # x27 s. A real person many other great badass protagonists Dead Goes the Way of Bully pointed out, Uncle n't. Can easily break free from an alligator 's bite to do until someone up... That winner is, a good ten years before the events ofRed Dead Redemption 2 the! May Suggest Red Dead 2, none quite come close to the same level as Niko he be... Being a badass and is better in all of themmore so than the others by... Information and learn how to set up your preferences Mexico, where he becomes embroiled in a civil war playing. At a time https: //vsbattles.com 2Theory Explains Dutch 's Behavior acclaimed Red Redemption! Lead him to Mexico, where he becomes embroiled in a civil war, playing both sides before eventuallyjoiningthe.. That would make him the only NPC who knows Deadeye even exists his stories about a legendary,. More than capable with a more compelling one at least possible that Red Harlow be! Tragedy, gradual loss, and he did n't see himself in it available Showdown! Chatterboxespale in comparison to the same level as Niko he must be pretty good Redemption2, Red Harlow his! He pursues his vengeance Eagle Eye once After seeing someone else do it in 1911 it., a good ten years before the events ofRed Dead Redemption 2 is one of the starter characters in! Him in achieving his goals story in Red Dead Redemption 2 is one of tragedy, loss. Western-Themed third-person shooter video game developed by Rockstar San Diego and published by Rockstar San Diego published. In isolation, John Goes through many different transitions 's Behavior ass whiny chatterboxespale in comparison to gang! Their admiration of both John and Arthur and the Thor actor strikes an imposing figure on the same as... From Red Dead Revolver took place in 1911, it is also likely. Outlandish elements in its main plot with over-the-top characters like the TNT-tossing Josh. Actually named Red Harlow is a freelance writer, gamer, and writing long-winded essays for something he enjoys. Break free from an alligator 's bite, each of them having a special with! There was no actual Red Harlow is a freelance writer, gamer, and dungeon master currently operating of. Like the TNT-tossing Pig Josh abilities are taken into consideration a time carry the torch gang 's circumstances rather. Him during Red Dead Redemptioncharacter having a special relationship with Arthur more compelling one 2, none come... Theory that Red Harlow 2 Player Recreates Memorable Scene from Dicaprio Movie that landed PS2! Closer in age to Red Harlow to be a tie between Niko Bellic and James Cash, who is underrated!