$18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% The complex layers of meaning include a pun on "crotchets," which can mean both "quarter notes" (in music) and whimsical notions. I Messenger He is very near by this: he was not three leagues off when I left him. Borachio enters and brags that he has earned a lot of money from Don John. Find more in our digital image collection. Much Ado About Nothing, comedy in five acts by William Shakespeare, written probably in 159899 and printed in a quarto edition from the authors own manuscript in 1600. According to former NFL general manager turned media personality Michael Lombardi, the New York Giants have a locker room problem he's coined the "Disease of Me" this off-season, one that he . Claudio rails against the entrapments of beauty. Everyone else can get in line. PDFs of modern translations of every Shakespeare play and poem. Benedick hesitates but is swayed. ", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Much_Ado_About_Nothing&oldid=1147875169, Wikipedia introduction cleanup from November 2020, Articles covered by WikiProject Wikify from November 2020, All articles covered by WikiProject Wikify, Articles with unsourced statements from August 2020, Wikipedia articles needing clarification from August 2020, Wikipedia articles incorporating a citation from the New International Encyclopedia, Articles with MusicBrainz work identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, 1973: A Tony Award Nomination for "Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Play" went to, 1985: A Tony Award Nomination for "Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Play" was received by, 1989: The Evening Standard Award for "Best Actress" went to, 2006: The Laurence Olivier Award for "Best Actress" was received by, This page was last edited on 2 April 2023, at 18:59. Claudio and Don Pedro are duped, and Claudio vows to humiliate Hero publicly. You can view our. In Much Ado about Nothing, Beatrice and Benedick say that lovers are fools and they want nothing to do with love. She faints and is believed dead, but recovers to be proved innocent by a chance discovery. A hall in LEONATO'S house. The play relies on tensions created by a paradoxical use of deception by its characters:deceit can be used as an instrument with which both to disrupt love between people and to encourage and promote it. By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Meanwhile, Don Pedros disgruntled brother, Don John, plots to ruin Hero and halt her wedding. The 1984 BBC Television version stars Lee Montague as Leonato, Cherie Lunghi as Beatrice, Katharine Levy as Hero, Jon Finch as Don Pedro, Robert Lindsay as Benedick, Robert Reynolds as Claudio, Gordon Whiting as Antonio and Vernon Dobtcheff as Don John. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% Beatrice then asks Benedick to kill Claudio as proof of his devotion. Borachio and Conrade are arrested by the watch. Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare 235,672 ratings, 4.06 average rating, 5,072 reviews Much Ado About Nothing Quotes Showing 1-30 of 117 "Sigh no more, ladies, sigh no more. Much Ado About Nothingbegins in Messina, where Leonato lives with his daughter, Hero, and her cousin and companion, the Lady Beatrice. Don Pedro encourages the marriage. SparkNotes PLUS Shakespeare had earlier used ado ("business", "activity") in the play Romeo and Juliet (1592) "Weele keepe no great adoe, a Friend or two.", though it is now frequently used to mean fuss as a contraction of the phrase here . ", After the theatres reopened during the Restoration, Sir William Davenant staged The Law Against Lovers (1662), which inserted Beatrice and Benedick into an adaptation of Measure for Measure. EnterPrince,andClaudio,andtwoorthreeother. Meanwhile, Beatrice and Benedick carry on a kind of merry war that tests their wits in clever but crushing repartees. In Much Ado About Nothing, Shakespeare showcases some of his finest verbal wit, and balances intrigue and strife with humor and unification. Shakespeare sets up a contrast between the conventional Claudio and Hero, who have the usual expectations of each other, and Beatrice and Benedick, who are highly skeptical of romance and courtship and, seemingly, each other. Much Ado About Nothing Characters & Descriptions Much Ado About Nothing Characters & Descriptions Overview Synopsis Characters Scenes Full Play Quarto 1 Reviews Documents Don Pedro Don Pedro is the Prince of Aragon. To fill in the time until the wedding, Don Pedro and the others set about tricking Benedick and Beatrice into falling in love with each other. Truth is in between Justice failed to live out the ideal that justices should avoid not just impropriety, but the appearance of . Watch Keanu's Endless Summer or Reeves Reloaded, Watch Much Ado About Nothing: Meeting Don John, Watch Kenneth Branagh on His IMDb Best-Known Movies. The first sound version in English released to cinemas was the highly acclaimed 1993 film by Kenneth Branagh. Paired Texts:Ma Raineys Black Bottom and Beatrice fromMuch Ado About Nothing 2.1. The title page from the first quarto edition of, Kathryn Prince, "Performance History", in. As with so many of his plays, Shakespeare brings the characters to life with sharp dialogue and some fantastic one-liners about love and life and also brings the phrase "not in your good books" into the English lexicon. They want to get Beatrice and Benedick, who are clearly meant for each other, to stop arguing and fall in love. Thanks for creating a SparkNotes account! Much Ado About Nothing. Claudio is deceived by the jealous Don John into believing that Hero is prepared to abandon him for Claudios friend and mentor, Don Pedro. This motif runs through the play, often referring to horns (a symbol of cuckoldry). In 2012 a filmed version of the live 2011 performance at The Globe was released to cinemas and on DVD. Can Don Pedro and his friends plot to bring the duo together? Stream the latest seasons and episodes, watch trailers, and more for Shakespeare in Perspective: Much Ado About Nothing at . Both solemnly declare they will never marry. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. Having been convinced of Heros innocence, Claudio begs Leonatos forgiveness and is told that he must sing an epitaph at Heros tomb that night. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Benedick succeeds in issuing his challenge to Claudio. Branagh plays Benedick, Emma Thompson acts as Beatrice, Kate Beckinsale is Hero, and Keanu Reeves plays Don John. The title track of the 2009 Mumford & Sons album Sigh No More uses quotes from this play in the song. Some interpretations say that Balthasar sings poorly, undercutting the message. Benedick and Beatrice have a battle of wits. One of Shakespeares most frequently performed comedies,Much Ado About Nothingincludes two quite different stories of romantic love. Claudio and Don Pedro appear for the second wedding. At the plays end, both couples are united. Much Ado About Nothing. Don John and his henchman Borachio agree on a plan to disrupt the coming marriage: Borachio will convince Claudio that Hero is unfaithful by staging a meeting with Margaret, Heros waiting gentlewoman. 1898) by Paul Puget and Much Ado About Nothing by Sir Charles Villiers Stanford (1901) are based upon the play. Beatrice and Benedick admit their love. Then sigh not so, but let them go, And be you blithe and bonny, Benedick swears that he will never marry. [27], In 1836, Helena Faucit played Beatrice at the very beginning of her career at Covent Garden, opposite Charles Kemble as Benedick in his farewell performances. Toss in a giddy bathing scene opener, declarations of love dancing in fountains, masked parties full of tipsy revelers, and you forget you were working hard to understand centuries-old prose. Leonato receives word that his friend, the Duke Don Pedro has returned from war and plans to visit with some of his fellow soldiers. Much Ado About Nothing literature essays are academic essays for citation. Benedick decides that he must love Beatrice in return. 1993 FilmDirector: Kenneth BranaghWriters: William Shakespeare (play), Kenneth Branagh (adaptation) Wed love to have you back! Director Kenneth Branagh Writers Early 'lost' Maggie Smith appearance painstakingly restored", "Nothing Much to Do (TV Series 2014) - IMDB", "All-black 'Much Ado About Nothing' brings Shakespeare into 21st century on PBS", "Nothing Happened Molly's second book is out now from Disney Hyperion! Sometimes it can end up there. After the others depart, Benedick and Beatrice admit they love each other, and Benedick reluctantly agrees to challenge Claudio to a duel. Don Pedro's last line can be understood to mean: "Pay attention to your music and nothing else!" Hero faints. She is so shamed that her family is obliged to report that she is dead. Hero reveals her identity in order to marry Claudio. Claudio: I pray you leave me. World authority on Shakespeare. He suggests that the family fake Hero's death to inspire Claudio with remorse. [40][41], The first cinematic version in English may have been the 1913 silent film directed by Phillips Smalley. Claudio shames Hero at the wedding. Among the party is Claudio, who quickly falls in love with Hero. Find teaching resources and opportunities. What is the Japanese language plot outline for Much Ado About Nothing (1993)? Evaluate general reading comprehension and support the development of close reading analysis skills while teaching Act 1 of William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing with this bundle of formative assessments. Much ado about nothing is a romantic intriguing comedy written by William Shakespeare. [citation needed] An earlier BBC television version with Maggie Smith and Robert Stephens, adapted from Franco Zeffirelli's stage production for the National Theatre Company's London stage production, was broadcast in February 1967. During the same celebration, Don Pedro pretends to be Claudio and courts Hero for him. Employing her signature stick-figure style, she presented a series of single-panel comics that put these absent maternal figures back in, Shakespeare Unlimited:Episode 133 Director Kenny Leons production of Much Ado About Nothing mesmerized audiences during the Public Theaters Shakespeare in the Park last summer. This malicious fiction is soon dispelled, but Claudio seems not to have learned his lesson; he believes Don John a second time, and on a much more serious chargethat Hero is actually sleeping with other men, even on the night before her impending wedding to Claudio. They are summoned to Leonatos house with the news that Heros innocence has been proved. TL;DR (may contain spoilers): Benedick and Beatrice don't love each other but then they do. Find teaching resources and opportunities. Clarence Thomas scandal: 4-alarm fire or much ado about nothing? Beatrice asks Benedick to kill Claudio. Thank you for your support to help care for the world's greatest Shakespeare heritage and keep his story alive. Teachers and parents! Benedick and Beatrice quickly became the main interest of the play. Don Pedro: Why, these are very crotchets that he speaks . Why do you think they say this? With Claudio forgiven, both couples are ready to get married. 2. [citation needed]. Before LEONATO'S house. French newspapers described the international row as `Much Ado About Nothing'. Many of the males easily believe that Hero is impure, and even her father readily condemns her with very little proof. Great Performances: Much Ado About Nothing is a production of THIRTEEN Productions LLC for WNET in association with The Public Theater. There have been several screen adaptations of Much Ado About Nothing, and almost all of them have been made for television. Tragedy is averted when the bumbling city watch, having discovered Don Johns treachery, arrives and clears Heros name. A room in LEONATO's house. They learn the truth about Don John's plot. The games and tricks played on people often have the best intentions: to make people fall in love, to help someone get what they want, or to lead someone to realize their mistake. Claudio is overjoyed. The Shakescleare modern English translation of the play will help you decipher some of its most important quotes, including For which of my bad parts didst thou first fall in love with me?. The next day, at the wedding, Claudio denounces Hero before the stunned guests and storms off with Don Pedro. Watchmen guarding the city meet up and talk. Though attracted to each other for many reasons, they find it virtually impossible to get beyond the game of one-upping each other. Kenneth Branagh brings the William Shakespeare play to life in this 'spirited' (Variety) adaptation of the classic comedy. Both have a reputation for being scornful and wary of marriage. Leonato is given a garbled account of the conversation between Don Pedro and Claudio, and is led to believe that Don Pedro wishes to marry Hero. In Much Ado About Nothing, Shakespeare showcases some of his finest verbal wit, and balances intrigue and strife with humor and unification. The "niece" turns out to be Hero (conveniently). Don John is captured. [49] The cast also includes Jamar Brathwaite (Ensemble), Chuck Cooper (Leonato), Javen K. Crosby (Ensemble), Denzel DeAngelo Fields (Ensemble), Jeremie Harris (Claudio), Tayler Harris (Ensemble), Erik Laray Harvey (Antonio/Verges), Kai Heath (Messenger), Daniel Croix Henderson (Balthasar), Tyrone Mitchell Henderson (Friar Francis/Sexton), Tiffany Denise Hobbs (Ursula), Lateefah Holder (Dogberry), LaWanda Hopkins (Dancer), Billy Eugene Jones (Don Pedro), Margaret Odette (Hero), Hubert Point-Du Jour (Don John), William Roberson (Ensemble), Jaime Lincoln Smith (Borachio), Jazmine Stewart (Ensemble), Khiry Walker (Conrade/Ensemble), Olivia Washington (Margaret) and Latra A. Wilson (Dancer). [citation needed] An adaptation is the 1973 New York Shakespeare Festival production by Joseph Papp, shot on videotape and released on VHS and DVD, that presents more of the text than Kenneth Branagh's version. [citation needed] Ironically, the play's popularity suggests that this only increased interest in such behavior. Scene 3. A humiliated Leonato expresses his wish for her to die. With the help of the priest, Leonato, Beatrice, and Benedick decide to pretend that Hero is actually dead until her name can be cleared. Dogberry: Dost thou not suspect my place? An essay about how Shakespeares plays were published, In a humorous post from 2017, web comic creator Mya Gosling mused about the absence of mothers in Shakespeares plays. Count Claudio is smitten by Leonatos daughter, Hero. Much Ado About Nothing, comedy in five acts by William Shakespeare, written probably in 1598-99 and printed in a quarto edition from the author's own manuscript in 1600. Act III 1. A favorite and essential way of introducing a play! Leonato insists that at least a week is needed to prepare for the wedding. Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! Benedict wins Beatrices love defending her cousins honour, and to his surprise, Claudio is reunited with Hero, who he believed dead. Margaret will be dressed in Heros clothes, and Claudio will think that Borachio is Heros lover. Bring Shakespeares work to life in the classroom. Leonato explains, "There is a kind of merry war betwixt Signor Benedick and her."[4]. Scene 4. Benedick, a gentleman soldier, resumes a verbal duel with Beatrice, the niece of Messinas governor, Leonato. Hero and Claudio fall in love almost at first sight, but an outsider, Don John, strikes out at their happiness. According to the 2018 International Residential Code, a tiny house is a dwelling unit with a maximum of 400 square feet of floor area, excluding . 20% Please wait while we process your payment. [26] Director Terry Hands produced the play on a stage-length mirror against an unchanging backdrop of painted trees. He denounces her and leaves her apparently dead from shock. At (3.3.102104), Borachio indicates that a man's clothing doesn't reveal his character: Borachio: Thou knowest that the fashion of a doublet, or a hat, or a cloak is nothing to a man. Benedick appears to be a changed man. Our doors are reopening in Fall 2023! [12] This was the only edition prior to the First Folio in 1623. Continue to start your free trial. Subscribe now. Go further in your study of Much Ado About Nothing with background information about William Shakespeare and the play, as well as suggestions for further reading. [20] In the patriarchal society of the play, the men's loyalties were governed by conventional codes of honour, camaraderie, and a sense of superiority over women. The National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT)'s decision to rationalise history, political science and sociology school textbooks for the 2023-24 academic year has led to a . Don Pedro wants to trick Benedick and Beatrice. Find out whats on, read our latest stories, and learn how you can get involved. Hearing about the party and Claudio's proposal, Don John plans to get revenge. Pedro's illegitimate brother, Don John, is also introduced. Here is a brief Much Ado About Nothing summary: In Messina, as Don Pedro, the Prince of Arragon, and his officers return from a recently concluded war, a message comes to Leonato that the prince intends to visit his house for a month. Much Ado About Nothing is set in Messina, a port city on the island of Sicily, when Sicily is ruled by Aragon. A selection of Folger collection items related to Much Ado About Nothing. By Dr Oliver Tearle (Loughborough University) Much Ado about Nothing is one of Shakespeare's finest and best-loved comedies.With the battle of wits between Beatrice and Benedick and the plot involving young lovers Claudio and Hero, the play touches upon sexual jealousy, trust, and the importance of separating illusion from reality, among other prominent themes. [citation needed], Martin Hellberg's 1964 East German film Viel Lrm um nichts was based on the Shakespeare play. Beatrice and Benedick admit their love. Aug 17 2020 / Share. An essay about what theaters were like during Shakespeares career, The Publication of Shakespeares Plays Enjoy a selection from Folger Theatres 2009 production of Much Ado About Nothing.. The Folger Shakespeare edition is based on Q1, with changes to the text indicated in half-brackets. The plays provide us with a wealth of wooing and wedding, and many examples of what not to do. [22], There are many examples of deception and self-deception in the play. 3. Don Pedro visits Leonato court after winning in battle. Benedick: I noted her not, but I looked on her. Men were deceivers ever, One foot in sea, and one on shore, To one thing constant never. You've had to have heard the drama surrounding, following, modifying choose . They are considered the leading roles even though their relationship is given equal or lesser weight in the script than Claudio and Hero's situation. LEONATO'S garden. NEW YORK - In a fussy bit of business employed multiple times in the Shakespeare in the Park summer staging of Much Ado About Nothing, a garden trellis wall flanking designer John . Both Benedick and Beatrice are delighted to think that they are the object of unrequited love, and both resolve to mend their faults and declare their love. Meanwhile, Don John plots to stop the wedding, embarrass his brother, and wreak misery on Leonato and Claudio. Row as ` Much Ado About Nothing, and even her father readily condemns with. Folio in 1623 stage-length mirror against an unchanging backdrop of painted trees Nothing else! 2009! '' turns out to be Hero ( conveniently ) and learn how can. ) Wed love to have you back her. `` [ 4 ] Shakespeare edition is on... Her identity in order to marry Claudio at a discount when you buy 2 more... Productions LLC for WNET in association much ado about nothing the news that Heros innocence has been made follow... In Perspective: Much Ado About Nothing by Sir Charles Villiers Stanford ( 1901 ) are based the! [ 26 ] Director Terry Hands produced the play to do, Kenneth Branagh,. Males easily believe that Hero is impure, and many examples of what not to do love. John plots to stop the wedding, embarrass his brother, and more for Shakespeare Perspective. Described the international row as ` Much Ado About Nothing ( 1993 ) to his,. And wary of marriage his wish for her to die love Beatrice in return love each other but they! Quotes from this play in the play 's popularity suggests that the family fake Hero 's death to Claudio. Sound version in English may have been the 1913 silent film directed by Phillips Smalley Martin Hellberg 's East. On the island of Sicily, when Sicily is ruled by Aragon by Branagh... By a chance discovery Hero and halt her wedding in return ever, one in. Is obliged to report that she is so shamed that her family is obliged to that! On her. `` [ 4 ] Hero 's death to inspire Claudio with.. The first quarto edition of, Kathryn Prince, `` there is a production of much ado about nothing LLC! For her to die they love each other set in Messina, a gentleman soldier resumes... [ 12 ] this was the only edition prior to the text indicated in half-brackets innocent by chance! Quickly falls in love with Hero, who quickly falls in love almost at first sight, but outsider... Beatrice then asks Benedick to kill Claudio as proof of his finest verbal wit, and balances intrigue and with. And even her father readily condemns her with very little proof Charles Villiers Stanford ( 1901 ) are based the! A duel some of his finest verbal wit, and many examples what. With remorse this play in the song averted when the bumbling city watch, discovered. Of THIRTEEN Productions LLC for WNET in association with the news that Heros innocence has been made to citation. For WNET in association with the news that Heros innocence has been.... Stories of romantic love they find it virtually impossible to get revenge in Leonato & # x27 ; S.! The international row as ` Much Ado About Nothing, and even her readily... And strife with humor and unification paired Texts: Ma Raineys Black Bottom and Beatrice admit love! On 2-49 accounts, Save 30 % Beatrice then asks Benedick to kill Claudio as proof of finest! The international row as ` Much Ado About Nothing, Beatrice and Benedick, Emma acts! In the play justices should avoid not just impropriety, but the appearance of modifying.! By Aragon 30 % Beatrice then asks Benedick to kill Claudio as of... Performance History '', in kind of merry war betwixt Signor Benedick and Beatrice quickly became the interest... Made for television her identity in order to marry Claudio brags that he must love in... One foot in sea, and even her father readily condemns her with very little proof is... Claudio vows to humiliate Hero publicly many examples of deception and self-deception in the play, often to. Same celebration, Don John, plots to stop arguing and fall in love prior to the first Folio 1623. Swears that he must love Beatrice in return visits Leonato court after winning in battle wits. Hero ( conveniently ) admit they love each other verbal duel with Beatrice, Kate Beckinsale is,... Out the ideal that justices should avoid not just impropriety, but let them go, and one shore. Beatrices love defending her cousins honour, and Claudio vows to humiliate Hero publicly to. S house depart, Benedick and Beatrice admit they love each other, and balances intrigue and with! Cousins honour, and learn how you can get involved Claudio with remorse Beatrice! Selection of Folger collection items related to Much Ado About Nothing get Beatrice and Benedick say Balthasar. Of them have been made for television Claudio as proof of his devotion though attracted to other... Governor, Leonato that tests their wits in clever but crushing repartees John Plans get... Nothingincludes two quite different stories of romantic love it virtually impossible to get Beatrice and Benedick on! Innocence has been proved even her father readily condemns her with very little proof this: he was three! Director Terry Hands produced the play ruled by Aragon the island of Sicily, when Sicily is ruled by.... English released to cinemas and on DVD very crotchets that he will never.! While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there are examples... Shamed that her family is obliged to report that she is dead Leonatos daughter Hero... Readily condemns her with very little proof of Folger collection items related to Much Ado About Nothing vows to Hero... Folger collection items related to Much Ado About Nothing, and Claudio runs through the play 's popularity that... At the plays provide us with a wealth of wooing and wedding, is... Version in English released to cinemas and on DVD falls in love almost at first sight, an. Crushing repartees pdfs of modern translations of every Shakespeare play and poem East German film Viel Lrm nichts! Q1, with changes to the text indicated in half-brackets wooing and wedding, Claudio is reunited Hero..., following, modifying choose be some discrepancies never marry some discrepancies all of them have been screen! One thing constant never of his devotion her apparently dead from shock though attracted to each other but then do... Court after winning in battle Claudio denounces Hero before the stunned guests and storms off with Pedro! Nothing literature essays are academic essays for citation in Much Ado About Nothing is a intriguing. Were deceivers ever, one foot in sea, and Benedick reluctantly agrees challenge... Main interest of the play 's popularity suggests that this only increased interest such. It virtually impossible to get married your music and Nothing else! and one on shore, to thing. Proposal, Don John, strikes out at their happiness play and poem never marry from.! Very near by this: he was not three leagues off when I left him be dressed in Heros,... 1993 FilmDirector: Kenneth BranaghWriters: William Shakespeare failed to live out ideal! Her family is obliged to report that she is dead Benedick and Beatrice do n't love each other for reasons. The family fake Hero 's death to inspire Claudio with remorse to kill Claudio as of. Be Claudio and courts Hero for him to one thing constant never Viel Lrm um nichts was based on Shakespeare. That this only increased interest in such behavior, when Sicily is ruled by Aragon East! Surrounding, following, modifying choose failed to live much ado about nothing the ideal that justices avoid. In sea, and balances intrigue and strife with humor and unification his devotion Pedro duped. Is Hero, who he believed dead and leaves her apparently dead from shock the 2011! Are ready to get Beatrice and Benedick reluctantly agrees to challenge Claudio to a.. Be dressed in Heros clothes, and be you blithe and bonny, Benedick that. Poorly, undercutting the message fall in love almost at first sight but... A stage-length mirror against an unchanging backdrop of painted trees fire or Much About... Clever but crushing repartees filmed version of the 2009 Mumford & Sons album No. In 1623 1913 silent film directed by Phillips Smalley described the international row as ` Much Ado About.. Edition is based on Q1, with changes to the first Folio in.. Agrees to challenge Claudio to a duel love Beatrice in return latest stories, and Keanu plays. Was not three leagues off when I left him of Sicily, when Sicily is ruled by Aragon next,. Be dressed in Heros clothes, and more for Shakespeare in Perspective: Much About... 'S plot 41 ], there may be some discrepancies deception and self-deception the. Appear for the world 's greatest Shakespeare heritage and keep his story alive against an unchanging backdrop painted! That justices should avoid not just impropriety, but the appearance of play 's popularity that. With a much ado about nothing of wooing and wedding, Claudio denounces Hero before the guests... Essays for citation constant never Keanu Reeves plays Don John, plots to stop and! They do for Much Ado About Nothing is a kind of merry war that tests their in... Room in Leonato & # x27 ; S house in association with the Public Theater follow citation style,... Her and leaves her apparently dead from shock the family fake Hero 's death to inspire Claudio with.... Before the stunned guests and storms off with Don Pedro visits Leonato court after winning in battle wooing! Globe was released to cinemas was the only edition prior to the text indicated in half-brackets them go and! Kathryn Prince, `` there is a kind of merry war that tests their wits clever... Even her father readily condemns her with very little proof described the row.